Six Sindh mayors rejected Muttahida Qaumi Movement-Pakistan (MQM-P) convener Khalid Maqbool Siddiqui's call for new provinces, affirming the province's integrity at a Karachi press conference on Friday.
- Mayors said only Article 239(4) allowed new provinces.
- They demanded an apology for mocking Sindh's culture.
- They warned any division would breach the Constitution.
Constitutional Limits
Karachi Mayor Murtaza Wahab, Sukkur Mayor Arsalan Islam Shaikh, Hyderabad Mayor Kashif Shoro, Larkana Mayor Anwar Luhar, Nawabshah Mayor Qazi Rasheed Bhatti and Mirpurkhas Mayor Abdul Rauf Ghori addressed a joint press conference at the Karachi Press Club. They declared Sindh's geographical integrity non‑negotiable and said the creation of new provinces could occur only under Article 239(4) of the Constitution. They added that Article 140A had no connection with provincial formation and that calls for a referendum departed from the constitutional framework. The six mayors demanded an apology for "mocking Sindh's culture and promoting ethnic politics."
Mayors' Statements
Wahab said hatred damaged any society and that the Pakistan People's Party believed in bringing people together. He reminded the audience that Sindh possessed a 5,000‑year history and that Karachi's history did not begin in 1947. He pointed to the shrine of Hazrat Abdullah Shah Ghazi as a symbol of the city's deep roots. Wahab recalled that ethnic divisions had been encouraged during his formative years, that Karachi had been the region's jewel in the 1970s, and that ethnic politics in the 1980s had divided communities, sparked fear, and led to strikes, extortion, kidnapping, terrorism and the replacement of the pen by the gun. He said peace returned only after immense sacrifices by political workers, journalists and law‑enforcement personnel. Wahab warned that Karachi must never revert to the conditions of the 1980s and 1990s.
Wahab also swiped at the Muttahida Qaumi Movement-Pakistan (MQM-P), noting that Siddiqui's press conference had not been attended by Mustafa Kamal and that a party divided by internal differences could not claim authority over Sindh's future. He said the dispute had shifted from Nine Zero to Bahadurabad and Raees Amrohvi Road. He stressed that the 1973 Constitution explicitly laid down the procedure for altering provincial boundaries and called Siddiqui's argument legally untenable. Wahab urged leaders to prioritize people's economic difficulties, citing Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP) Chairman Bilawal Bhutto Zardari's stance on public issues. He described himself as an Urdu‑speaking Sindhi, warned against applying different standards to Sindh and Punjab, and called for constitutional principles and dialogue to resolve disputes.
Shaikh said the press conference responded to Siddiqui's recent remarks, which he called contrary to facts. He argued that the mayors represented the people's mandate because they had been elected through public votes. Shaikh added that adding "United" to a party's name did not guarantee unity, pointing to recent internal disagreements and the Muttahida Qaumi Movement-Pakistan (MQM-P)'s avoidance of elections when it anticipated poor results. He said Siddiqui's 40‑minute press conference ignored the country's economic challenges and accused the Muttahida Qaumi Movement-Pakistan (MQM-P) of presiding over a period of violence in Sindh.
Shaikh highlighted Sindh's status as Quaid‑i‑Azam Muhammad Ali Jinnah's province, its 5,000‑year civilisation, and its Sufi heritage. He demanded an apology and the withdrawal of remarks that compared Sindhi culture to African jungles. He warned the Muttahida Qaumi Movement-Pakistan (MQM-P) not to provoke Sindhis or ridicule their identity and said no one could stop elected representatives from defending the province. Shaikh threatened that if the current approach continued, the next press conference could be held at Nine Zero alongside Karachi's urban residents. He declared that Karachi was not anyone's personal property.
Shaikh defended the Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP)'s performance, saying the party had restored peace in Karachi and that the city no longer faced the conditions of the past. He noted that previous mayors had complained about a lack of authority, whereas the incumbent mayor now accessed a district Annual Development Programme budget worth billions of rupees. Shaikh praised Wahab for working continuously toward the city's development.
