The Federation of Pakistan Chambers of Commerce and Industry (FPCCI) warned on Tuesday that the Federal Board of Revenue's decision to separate sales tax and income tax administration threatens to weaken efforts to curb tax evasion.
- FPCCI warned the administrative split will increase the compliance burden on businesses.
- The move risks undermining the current 10.3 per cent tax-to-GDP ratio.
- Leaders urged the Ministry of Finance to reconsider the policy and consult stakeholders.
Risks to Tax Administration
FPCCI President Atif Ikram Sheikh stated that reversing the unified Inland Revenue administration breaks a vital mechanism for cross-verifying tax records. He explained that integrated oversight allowed authorities to identify discrepancies between a business's sales and its declared income. According to Sheikh, businesses that conceal turnover to evade sales tax often understate their actual income as well. He noted that dismantling the integration framework introduced in 2009 could further undermine the national tax-to-GDP ratio, which currently stands at 10.3 per cent against the government's target of 15 per cent.
Impact on Business Compliance
FPCCI Senior Vice President Saquib Fayyaz Magoon argued that the administrative split places additional scrutiny on registered manufacturers, importers, and distributors rather than bringing unregistered businesses into the tax net. He warned that compliant businesses could face separate notices, dual oversight, and conflicting interpretations of commercial transactions by different tax commissioners. This shift increases compliance costs for documented firms.
FPCCI Vice President and Regional Chairman Sindh Abdul Mohamin Khan urged the Ministry of Finance and the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) to focus on strengthening institutional capacity and improving integrated data analytics instead. He stated that duplicating administrative structures creates difficulties for documented businesses while leaving the informal sector outside the tax net. Khan called for formal consultations with the business community before the government implements changes that affect industrial competitiveness.
FPCCI Vice President Asif Sakhi highlighted that a 1.7 per cent decline in domestic sales tax collection, contrasted with a 17 per cent increase in import-stage collections, exposed weaknesses in the current system. He said this trend indicated that the tax machinery places greater pressure on documented trade at borders and ports while failing to expand the domestic tax base. The FPCCI leadership collectively advised the authorities to maintain common transaction records to ensure transparency and efficiency.
