ESPN college football commentator Kirk Herbstreit faced public backlash on November 12, 2026, after he posted a video of himself feeding his dog steak inside a New York City restaurant.
- Herbstreit shared footage of himself feeding his golden retriever, Peter, from a plate at a steakhouse.
- Broadcaster Craig Carton criticized the act, calling the presence of a dog in a restaurant disgusting.
- Social media users questioned Herbstreit's etiquette and his decision to bring a pet into a dining establishment.
Criticism of Herbstreit's Dining Choice
The controversy began when Herbstreit uploaded a video to Instagram showing him chopping a steak and feeding it to Peter, his golden retriever. Peter became Herbstreit's regular road companion following the death of his previous dog, Ben, in November 2024. Herbstreit frequently travels with the dog during his various football broadcasting assignments for ESPN's College GameDay and Prime Video's Thursday Night Football.
Craig Carton, host of The Craig Carton Show on the Fox News Digital outlet OutKick, led the criticism against the broadcaster. While Carton clarified that he should not be perceived as anti-dogs, he expressed strong disapproval regarding the setting of the meal. Carton stated that he did not want to eat at a steakhouse next to a dog, describing the practice as disgusting.
Public Reaction to Viral Video
Following Carton's remarks, numerous NFL fans joined the debate on social media to condemn the ESPN personality. One user questioned Herbstreit's etiquette, asking why anyone would bring a pet to a steakhouse and suggesting the broadcaster showed zero regard for other diners. Another commenter wrote that while they love dogs, they believed Herbstreit had deep issues he needed to address.
The incident sparked a divide between those who saw no harm in the interaction and those who argued that the broadcaster crossed a line of social conduct. Despite the backlash from critics and fans, Herbstreit continued to face scrutiny over his decision to bring his pet into the restaurant environment. The video remained a focal point of discussion regarding public dining standards and the behavior of high-profile media figures.
