The map is not the machinery

Interior Minister Mohsin Naqvi has described the governance system · File photo
Interior Minister Mohsin Naqvi has described the governance system · File photo
Interior Minister Mohsin Naqvi proposed seeking public opinion on new administrative units on November 18, 2026, as the debate over creating new provinces returned to Pakistan's political agenda.
  • Interior Minister Mohsin Naqvi described the current governance system as a failure.
  • Planning Minister Ahsan Iqbal called for administrative reform and stronger local governments.
  • The government denied drafting a constitutional amendment to create new provinces.

Debate over administrative units

The government's stance on the issue remains inconsistent. While some officials claim total ignorance regarding any formal discussions, Defence Minister Khawaja Asif recently described the creation of new provinces as a nearly completed deal. Planning Minister Ahsan Iqbal advocated for administrative reform while emphasizing the necessity of strengthening local governments. This discussion is not new. It reflects a long-standing struggle over whether power should reside with the federation, provincial governments, or elected representatives closer to the citizens. Proponents argue that new provinces could make government more accessible and manageable. However, changing maps alone will not fix a system where authority, resources, and accountability remain concentrated at the top. The primary challenge is ensuring that decisions occur near the people affected by them, with clear responsibility for outcomes.

History of power devolution

Pakistan's history with devolution reveals a pattern where civilian governments endorse the concept in principle but resist it in practice. Successive administrations often proved reluctant to transfer meaningful political, administrative, and financial authority to elected local representatives. Military regimes, such as the one led by Gen Pervez Musharraf in 2001, promoted local government systems, but these were often criticized for serving the regime's political interests and were dismantled once the military left office. The 18th Amendment, passed in 2010, mandated that each province establish local government and devolve authority. Sixteen years later, a significant gap persists between that constitutional promise and the everyday experience of citizens. Provincial autonomy did not automatically guarantee devolution within the provinces. Consequently, provincial governments often replicate the same centralizing habits they criticize at the federal level.

Principles for future governance

The debate on new provinces must address why constitutional arrangements should prioritize representation and public confidence over personalized advantage. Creating a new province that merely shifts the center of power from one city to another, without sharing authority with districts and towns, will only reproduce existing problems on a smaller scale. Any proposal must be tested against evidence regarding population, geography, and service delivery. The government should define the purpose of new units, clarify the powers and resources each will possess, and publish a detailed blueprint before seeking public input. Without transparency regarding boundaries, assets, and finances, any consultation risks asking citizens to endorse a label rather than a functional governing structure.

Related coverage