The Peshawar High Court on Thursday set aside the acquittal of a man accused of killing his brother and two sisters in a Kohat triple murder case, sentencing him to death. According to the judgment, on September 30, 2022, complainant Asia Bibi lodged a report at the Cantonment Police Station in Kohat, alleging that her son, Haider Khan, entered their house and opened fire.
The shooting killed his brother Salman and two sisters, Laila and Aleena, while she herself escaped the gunfire. The incident reportedly stemmed from a domestic dispute.
After recording statements of 15 prosecution witnesses, the trial court acquitted the accused on January 4, 2024. The provincial government challenged the acquittal before the Peshawar High Court, with Additional Advocate General Law Lajbar Khan representing the government.
A division bench comprising Justice Sahibzada Asadullah and Justice Farah Jamshed allowed the State's appeal against the trial court's acquittal of Haider Khan. The detailed judgment, authored by Justice Sahibzada Asadullah, observed that the prosecution evidence had not been properly assessed by the trial court, which overlooked the accused's confession, medical evidence, recovery of the weapon and forensic report.
In its detailed judgment, Justice Sahibzada Asadullah observed that the testimony of the victims' mother was a significant and sensitive aspect of the case, as she was not only the mother of the three deceased but also of the accused. During the trial, she had stated that she did not oppose his acquittal.
However, the court held that this did not amount to a complete retraction of her initial complaint, and that her original report and subsequent testimony had to be considered together. The court expressed sympathy for the mother's grief and suffering but made it clear that sympathy could not take the place of law and evidence.
The bench examined the accused's confessional statement in detail, observing that, for a confession to carry legal weight, it must be recorded voluntarily and its contents must be corroborated by other evidence. According to the judgment, the judicial magistrate had sent the police and prosecutor out of the courtroom, allowed the accused 30 minutes to reflect, and personally recorded his statement in Pashto before reading it back to him.
Although the record contained some inconsistencies regarding the accused's handover after the confession, the court found that the contents of the statement were consistent with the crime scene, medical evidence and forensic report. The judgment further stated that a 30-bore pistol was recovered on the accused's identification.
Forensic examination of 10 spent cartridges recovered from three different locations inside the house established that all had been fired from the same pistol. The court described this as an important and independent scientific link between the accused and the crime.
Medical evidence also confirmed the firearm injuries sustained by the victims and the resulting deaths. The court observed that a mere difference of opinion was not sufficient to interfere with an acquittal in an appeal.
However, misreading of evidence or failure to consider material evidence by the trial court could provide valid grounds for such intervention. In the present case, the trial court had attached exceptional weight to the mother's statement during the trial while failing to properly assess the confession, recovery of the weapon and forensic evidence, thereby rendering the acquittal unsustainable.
While determining the sentence, the court also considered the accused's age, alleged illiteracy, family circumstances and other possible mitigating factors. However, it held that the killing of three people was a deliberate and continuous act and that no sufficient mitigating circumstances existed to justify a sentence of life imprisonment.
The bench further made it clear that a premeditated murder committed in the name of so-called honour could not be given a reduced sentence on the grounds of sudden provocation. Allowing the government's appeal, the PHC set aside Haider Khan's acquittal and sentenced him to death on three separate counts under Section 302(b) of the Pakistan Penal Code for the murders of his brother Salman and sisters Laila and Aleena.
The court also sentenced him to one year's imprisonment and imposed a fine of Rs10,000 under Section 15-AA. In case of default in payment of the fine, he will undergo an additional month in prison.
The court further directed that the accused, who was present in the court, be taken into custody immediately and sent to prison.
