Justice Muhammad Azam Khan warned judges and lawyers in Manchester on Friday that artificial intelligence must assist in legal processes but never decide court cases. In his address, titled The Rule of Law in an Age of Environmental and Technological Change, Justice Khan stated that the judiciary must keep pace with technology without compromising fundamental principles.
- While he initially approached AI with suspicion, he acknowledged that the technology is genuinely useful for processing thousands of pages of documents in minutes.
- However, the judge drew a firm line regarding the application of AI.
- "An algorithm has no conscience," he said, warning that systems trained on past data carry "all our old prejudices" inside them.
While he initially approached AI with suspicion, he acknowledged that the technology is genuinely useful for processing thousands of pages of documents in minutes. "If technology can shorten that wait, I'm in favour of it," he said, noting that such tools could help clear court backlogs where cases often wait for years.
However, the judge drew a firm line regarding the application of AI. He argued that machines cannot be asked to explain themselves, noting that courts decide matters as significant as imprisonment or child custody.
"An algorithm has no conscience," he said, warning that systems trained on past data carry "all our old prejudices" inside them. Justice Khan urged lawyers to verify the output of AI tools, citing instances where court submissions referenced non-existent cases.
He warned that carelessness could lead to "automating discrimination" under the guise of efficiency. He maintained that decisions affecting liberty, livelihood, or family must not be handed to a system that cannot be cross-examined or held accountable.
He added that anyone affected by a decision has the right to know how it was reached and to challenge it. Failing to protect this right, he said, "strikes at the integrity of the court."
Turning to environmental issues, Justice Khan argued that climate change has shifted from a matter of policy to a fundamental right. He cited floods, pollution, and resource shortages as factors that directly impact human dignity and security.
The judge pointed to Pakistan's experience with devastating floods and highlighted Article 9A of the country's Constitution, which recognizes the right to a clean, healthy, and sustainable environment. He stated that this provision makes environmental protection a legal responsibility rather than a mere government policy.
Justice Khan concluded that development and environmental protection must go "hand in hand," requiring a balance of constitutional rights, scientific evidence, and the needs of future generations.
