Us supreme court declines free speech challenge to california's implicit bias courses

Us supreme court declines free speech challenge to californias implicit bias courses · File photo
Us supreme court declines free speech challenge to california's implicit bias courses · File photo

U.S. Supreme Court declined to hear challenge to California's implicit bias training rule for doctors on Nov. 16, 2026.

  • Rule requires physicians to complete 50 hours of CME on implicit bias.
  • Petition argued rule violated First Amendment rights.
  • Three justices sought to hear case but fell one vote short.

Supreme Court Ruling

The Court rejected a petition that questioned a 2019 law mandating that all medical courses in California include instruction on implicit bias. The decision, announced Monday, Nov. 16, 2026, came after a vote of 4‑3, with Justices Clarence Thomas, Samuel Alito and Neil Gorsuch favoring the case. The Court did not grant the petition, leaving the state rule in place.

Policy Context

California law requires licensed physicians to complete at least 50 hours of continuing medical education (CME) every two years. In 2019, lawmakers added a clause that all CME courses must contain curriculum on implicit bias. The rule applies to every medical discipline, including ophthalmology, where Dr. Azadeh Khatibi practices.

Petitioners' Arguments

Dr. Khatibi, an ophthalmologist, and the activist group Do No Harm argued that the training compels instructors to deliver an ideological message, violating the First Amendment. The attorneys for the physician said the training sends a damaging message to private practitioners. They claimed that the government cannot conscript private actors to deliver its forced message, though it may regulate its own speech.

Lower Court Decisions

Earlier courts dismissed Dr. Khatibi's challenge, ruling that the CME courses represent the government's own speech and therefore do not trigger First Amendment restrictions. The lower courts upheld the 2019 mandate, allowing the state to enforce the implicit bias curriculum.

The Supreme Court's refusal to hear the case leaves California's implicit bias training requirement intact. The decision confirms that the state can continue to mandate CME content on implicit bias for all physicians, while the petitioners' First Amendment claim remains unresolved. The ruling also signals that the Court will not intervene in similar state‑level educational mandates unless a majority of justices deem the issue urgent.

Related coverage